Manitoba·New
A provincially run Manitoba facility that creates crucial materials used to detect cancer has once again failed its Health Canada inspection, for many of the same reasons it failed its last inspection in late 2023.
Winnipeg Cyclotron facility failed reinspection for issues including product sterilization, lack of training
Kristin Annable, Caroline Barghout · CBC News
·
A provincially run Manitoba facility that creates crucial materials used to detect cancer has once again failed its Health Canada inspection, for many of the same reasons it failed a late 2023 inspection.
Earlier this year, CBC News reportedthe Winnipeg Cyclotron Facility — the sole producer of medical isotopes in Manitoba — was found non-compliant by Health Canada during its last routine inspection, in late October.
A new report released last weekshows it failed its reinspection in April after the regulator found five deficiencies,including problems with the sterilization of products, investigations into defective products and a lack of training.
"It raises suspicion if there are deficiencies that continue to not be completely addressed," said Dr. John Levin, a nuclear medicine physician at Winnipeg's Health Sciences Centre, which is also where the Winnipeg Cyclotron Facility is located.
This is the fifth time the facility has failed its inspection in the last decade.
- Winnipeg facility that produces essential cancer-screening material fails 4th Health Canada inspection
The isotopes produced in Winnipeg are used to create the radioactive material — often called a tracer — that is injected into patients during a positron emission tomography, or PET, scan.
The most common tracer uses a form of radioactive sugar and accumulates in abnormal spots to highlight possible tumours in a scan. That can help a doctor diagnose whether someone has cancer, how far it has spread, whether it has responded to therapy or if a cancer has come back.
No PET scans affected: Shared Health
No PET scans have been affected by the most recentfailure and there is no risk to Manitobans, said a Shared Health spokesperson. The facility was shut down for four days this week for "annual preventative maintenance," theprovincial health agency spokesperson said.
A Health Canada spokesperson said the facility had delays in addressing the problems found in the facility in the fall.
Further enforcement options are on the table, said the spokesperson, which could include temporarily pulling the facility's licence.
That's what almost happened to the Winnipeg facility after it failed a2017 inspection. At that point, however, the facility wasable to demonstrate "sufficient progress on the outstanding corrective actions" to maintain its licence, Shared Health previously said.
WATCH | A February report on the facility's 4th Health Canada failure:
4 months ago Duration 3:15
Winnipeg facility that produces essential cancer-screening material fails inspection for 4th time
Experts have been saying for months the closure of the crucial facility is a real risk.
If the facility loses its licence, isotopes would have to be shipped from Saskatchewan. They have a short shelf life and the extra time getting them into Manitoba would mean fewer PET scans, Levin previously told CBC.
That could mean doing only 10 scans a day instead of 20, he said earlier this year.
The facility, which opened in 2010, also failed its 2020 inspection and its first recorded inspection in 2013, which found 21 deficiencies, including issues with disinfection, poor documentation and testing procedures.
New radiochemist hired
Since the facility failed the late 2023 inspection, it has hired a new radiochemist, made changes to its organizational structure and implemented sterility tests, Shared Healthtold CBC.
The facility isworking with Health Canada to address the deficiencies and bring it into compliance, the spokesperson said.
Of the five deficiencies found in the latest inspection, four were also noted in 2023, "which reflects that not all of the complex remediation work has been completed yet," wrote the spokesperson.
Levin doesn't work in the facility, but as a nuclear medicine physician is responsible for reporting on PET scans and works with the facility.
He says the constant failures suggest the real issue is with the leadership of the facility.
"It's a difficult thing to run, and you need specific people for it. And I think that the leadership hasn't been collaborative enough," he said.
Health Canadais reviewing the facility's action plan for addressing the noted problems. Another inspection is expectedin the coming months.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Kristin Annable
Reporter
Kristin Annable is a member of CBC's investigative unit based in Winnipeg. She has won several RTDNAs for her work, including a national RTDNA for her investigation into deaths in police custody. She can be reached at kristin.annable@cbc.ca.
CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices|
About CBC NewsCorrections and clarifications|Submit a news tip|
Related Stories
- Winnipeg facility that produces essential cancer-screening material fails 4th Health Canada inspection
- Medical isotopes: What are the alternatives?
